Skip to main content

Rhythm Innovations

The 94% Blind Spot: Why Compliance Isn’t the Same as Safety

Why FMCSA data alone can’t tell the whole underwriting story

94.1%FMCSA-regulated carriers without an official safety rating (2023)

3.17MRoadside inspection events in 2025

25.9%2025 inspections that were full Level I inspections

Source: FMCSA 2024 Pocket Guide (2023 ratings) and FMCSA Analysis & Information 2025 calendar-year inspection reporting. See source notes.

For the commercial transportation insurance market, that distinction matters. A carrier may have valid operating authority and a clean-looking regulatory record while still presenting meaningful operational or loss exposure. Conversely, a carrier with an old citation may now have stronger controls than a snapshot suggests. The underwriting question is not simply whether a carrier is compliant. It is whether the risk is understood, changing, and being actively controlled.

The math behind the blind spot

In FMCSA’s 2024 Pocket Guide, based on 2023 carrier data, 716,558 of 761,681 regulated motor carriers had no official safety rating. Only 45,123 carried a Satisfactory, Conditional, or Unsatisfactory rating. Among interstate freight carriers specifically, 670,299 of 710,646, or approximately 94.3%, were unrated. [1]

For an illustrative portfolio of 1,000 carriers with the same distribution, approximately 941 would have no official rating. A screening process that treated a formal FMCSA rating as its only safety judgment would have no formal rating to consult for nearly all of them. That is a gap in one particular data field, not proof that the carriers lack all federal inspection or crash history.

FMCSA’s Safety Measurement System (SMS) does provide additional, frequently refreshed intelligence from roadside inspections, violations, and state-reported crashes. It is indispensable. But FMCSA expressly distinguishes SMS percentile rankings, which prioritize enforcement, from a federal safety fitness rating. Some carriers also lack enough relevant inspection events to receive a percentile in a particular category. [2]

Roadside inspections: millions of events, still an incomplete picture

FMCSA recorded 3,172,200 roadside inspection events in calendar year 2025. Of those events, 1,384,804 had no recorded violations; 1,787,396 had at least one violation; and 645,155 involved at least one out-of-service violation. Approximately 821,724 were Level I full driver-and-vehicle inspections, or 25.9% of all inspection events. [3][4]

These are inspection events, not unique trucks, drivers, or carriers. One truck or carrier may be inspected repeatedly, while another receives few or no inspections. They cannot be divided by the number of registered carriers to calculate the probability that an individual truck was inspected. And not every inspection examines the same systems: Level III, for example, focuses on driver credentials and administrative requirements rather than a full mechanical examination. [4][5]

That is the practical underwriting limitation. An inspection can establish what an officer observed at a particular point in time. It cannot, by itself, establish how consistently a carrier maintains vehicles, manages fatigue, coaches risky driving, verifies corrective actions, or responds to events between inspections.

Compliance and safety are related. They are not interchangeable.

Compliance asks: Did the carrier meet the applicable regulatory requirement when evaluated?

Safety asks: How effectively does the carrier identify, prevent, control, and learn from risks during everyday operations?

A carrier can be legally compliant and still have weak operational discipline. A driver can hold a valid CDL and still display deteriorating driving behavior. A maintenance program can produce completed inspection forms without timely correction of recurring defects. And a prior Satisfactory rating may say little about how controls are operating today. FMCSA itself has acknowledged that traditional ratings are snapshots and are not designed for continuous monitoring. [6]

This is not an argument against compliance. Regulatory compliance is the floor. Safety performance and documented operational control are the fuller underwriting picture.

The information insurers may never see in FMCSA alone

Federal crash data are also subject to reporting thresholds. Generally, an FMCSA-reportable crash must involve an applicable commercial vehicle and a fatality, immediate medical treatment away from the scene, or a disabling-damage tow-away. Lower-severity crashes, near misses, adverse driving events, and many early incident notifications can fall outside that dataset. FMCSA crash involvement records generally do not establish fault, and its crash preventability review is a distinct process. [7][8]

Meanwhile, the financial story may be changing before the regulatory story appears: late-reported accidents, missing vehicle or driver exposure, claim-development patterns, deteriorating reserves, repeat incident types, or a breakdown in corrective-action closure. An annual renewal packet may not reveal these changes until months later.

The next underwriting advantage is connecting risk, incident, and loss

At Rhythm Innovations, our approach to insurance risk intelligence is built around three connected questions: What is changing in the exposure? What actually happened? And what is the financial consequence?

Premium IQ™  |  Understand changing exposure. Connect fleet and operational changes to underwriting review, premium adequacy, renewal readiness, and potential premium leakage. A carrier’s vehicles, drivers, and operations do not stand still between policy anniversaries.

Incident IQ™  |  Know about the event sooner. Bring incident signals, initial facts, relevant evidence, reporting timelines, ownership, and follow-up into a structured workflow. Earlier awareness can support triage, evidence preservation, and informed escalation before the event becomes a surprise claim.

Claims IQ™  |  Understand loss development and response. Connect reported claims and loss information with incident history, reporting lag, severity, emerging development, and corrective actions to support claims visibility and better portfolio decisions.

Together with SaferFleet™ and a documented operational-control process, these capabilities support a more useful management loop: signal, decision, accountable owner, corrective action, proof, and verified closure. The objective is not to replace FMCSA, issue a federal rating, or guarantee a lower premium. It is to add context, recency, and evidence to insurance decisions that otherwise rely too heavily on historical snapshots.

What each insurance stakeholder should be asking

Risk retention groups and captives: Can we see preventable loss drivers early enough to intervene, and can we demonstrate that members changed their operating controls?

MGAs and program administrators: Are vehicle counts, driver exposure, eligibility, pricing adequacy, and safety controls changing between submissions and renewal?

Retail agents and brokers: Can we bring a more defensible risk narrative to underwriting, supported by documented actions rather than only declarations and historic loss runs?

A useful next step is to examine every transportation book across four distinct dimensions: (1) formal safety rating status; (2) recent roadside-inspection and SMS-data sufficiency; (3) operational-control evidence; and (4) incident-to-claim completeness and development. The intersection, not any single score, is where stronger underwriting conversations begin.

The question to carry into the next renewal

If a carrier has no federal safety rating, limited recent roadside inspection data, and a clean loss run, what evidence do we have that it is operating safely today?

That is not a reason to automatically decline the risk. It is a reason to ask better questions and seek better evidence.

Know before. Act before. Prove it.

Sources and methodology

[1] FMCSA, 2024 Pocket Guide to Large Truck and Bus Statistics, table 3-4, 2023 ratings, MCMIS snapshot January 26, 2024. https://www.fmcsa.dot.gov/safety/data-and-statistics/2024-pocket-guide-large-truck-and-bus-statistics

[2] FMCSA, CSA Frequently Asked Questions and Safety Measurement System methodology, carrier ratings and data sufficiency. https://csa.fmcsa.dot.gov/HelpCenter/GetFullFAQsPage

[3] FMCSA, A&I Enforcement Programs, Roadside Inspection Activity, calendar year 2025, MCMIS snapshot September 25, 2026. https://ai.fmcsa.dot.gov/EnforcementPrograms/Inspections

[4] FMCSA, A&I Enforcement Programs, Roadside Inspections by Level, calendar year 2025. https://ai.fmcsa.dot.gov/EnforcementPrograms/Inspections?type=ByLevel

[5] CVSA, North American Standard Inspection Levels. https://cvsa.org/inspections/all-inspection-levels/

[6] FMCSA, Safety Fitness Determinations, explanation of snapshot limits and investigation-dependent ratings. https://www.fmcsa.dot.gov/regulations/safety-fitness-determinations

[7] FMCSA, DataQs, criteria for reportable crashes. https://dataqs.fmcsa.dot.gov/HelpCenter/Faqs?faq_id=21

[8] FMCSA, Crash Preventability Determination Program, reporting versus preventability. https://www.fmcsa.dot.gov/safety/crash-preventability-determination-program-faqs